So tonight was the revival of Evita. This a show that I had seen on Broadway a couple of time with Patti LuPone and Mandy Patinkin, who both won Tony Awards for their performances. Bob Gunton played Peron in that production. I have listened to the Original Broadway Cast Recording so many times that I pretty much know the entire score. I later saw the movie featuring Madonna, Antonio Banderas and Jonathan Pryce. Madonna was better than expected but she was no Patti LuPone.
I ran into Shawn Sawyer in FINCO before leaving Nassau for this vacation and he informed that he had seen this Evita revival and he did not like it. One problem that he thought may have caused him not to like it was that the ‘Eva’ alternate had performed the day that he saw the show. Apart from that, he said that the show was just not something that he had enjoyed. I was therefore curious as to how one of my favorite musicals would fare with a new working.
After an early dinner we arrived at the Adelphi Theatre and headed to our very good seats, fourth row center, in the stalls. This production also begins with archive footage. This time the footage was not of ‘Eva’ as an actress but of the funeral procession. This then moved into the actors mourning ‘Eva’s’ death on stage and the introduction of ‘Che’. One of the mourners turns out the be the actress who will be playing ‘Eva’ and once she removes her black mourning clothes she is that character for the rest of the show.
When I first heard her sing, I thought “well, she is no Patti LuPone” but as the show progressed I thought “Wow, I’m happy she is no Patti LuPone”. Elena Roger is a petite Argentine woman. She is a brilliant dancer, a very powerful actress and quite a good singer. Now I love Patti LuPone, she is an incredibly powerful performer but sometimes that power makes her bigger than life and one ends up focusing on the actress rather than the character. Having not ever seen Elena Roger in anything, I felt somehow more attached to her ‘Eva’ than I had been to Patti’s. It’s sort of the Nathan Lane thing that Nico wrote about in her review of Butley and it’s kind of what happened to Greg Lampkin when he appeared in 12 Angry Men in Nassau. Everyone wanted to laugh at his serious character because it was Greg and that’s what they expected from him. I still don’t think that anyone can sing ‘Eva’ like Patti but overall I preferred this ‘Eva’ performance tonight.
Matt Rawle did an equally brilliant job as ‘Che’ and is equally as strong in his voice as Mandy Patinkin. Rawle’s ‘Che’ was different in a few ways, as the focus of the character was changed somewhat from the Original Broadway Production. ‘Che’ was not dressed in fatigues and manhandled by military officers as he got involved in the action but was much more of a narrator. His interaction with the other characters happened when the songs specifically called for them. His rendition of ‘And The Money Kept Rolling In (And Out)’ was equally as brilliant as Mandy’s and again having never seen him it was nice to not think of the star quality of the performer.
Philip Quast was the best ‘Peron’ that I’ve seen. A very strong singer and actor who brings ‘Juan Peron’ to life and exudes power when needed and self doubt when necessary.
The staging is quite different from what I’ve seen and the biggest change is the choreography by Rob Ashford. Dance is used a lot more in this production and subtle versions of the Tango feature prominently throughout. It’s used most creatively during the opening ‘Requiem For Evita’. The staging of ‘The Art Of The Possible’ is also different. This time there are no musical chairs but the generals actually wrestle for their position and in the end ‘Peron’ plays dirty to win his position.
The main thing I thought about as I watched this musical was “What the hell has happened to Andrew Lloyd Webber?” There was Jesus Christ Superstar then Evita and then? As Peron sings in this show, “Then again, it would be foolish not to quit while you’re ahead.” Lloyd Webber didn’t. While Nico is a fan of Cats (because of T. S. Eliot mainly), what follows Evita is, in my opinion dreck. Nico says it because he stopped working with Tim Rice but it’s not just the lyrics to his later shows, it’s also the music. But this go round, I must give credit where credit is due. Hands down Stephen Sondheim is my favorite Broadway composer but Andrew Lloyd Webber has written a brilliant score for Evita.
This production of Evita was very even and absolutely worth seeing. I would see it again if the opportunity presented itself and I will probably purchase the cast recording but I must admit that I would be torn as to which one to listen to because, at the end of the day, purely based on vocal ability Patti and Mandy are tough acts to follow.



